Consensus Panel

← Back to Glossary

Definition

A consensus panel is a group of experts convened to evaluate evidence and reach agreement on recommendations, standards, or conclusions when definitive empirical evidence is insufficient or conflicting. Panel members bring diverse expertise and perspectives to synthesize available evidence and professional judgment.

Correct Scientific Usage

Consensus panels follow structured processes to minimize bias and promote transparency. Well-conducted consensus methods include systematic evidence review, explicit criteria for reaching consensus, documentation of dissenting views, and acknowledgment of evidence limitations.

Scientists distinguish between consensus based on overwhelming empirical evidence and consensus reflecting expert opinion when evidence is limited. The strength of consensus-based recommendations depends on both the quality of underlying evidence and the rigor of the consensus process.

Common Misunderstandings

Consensus panels are sometimes assumed to produce definitive answers when they often address questions where evidence is incomplete or contradictory. The term ‘consensus’ can suggest universal agreement when panels may involve substantial disagreement, qualified conclusions, or acknowledgment of uncertainty.

There's also confusion between scientific consensus (broad agreement within the scientific community based on accumulated evidence) and consensus panel recommendations (specific guidance from a selected expert group).

Why It Matters

Understanding consensus panels helps evaluate the strength of their recommendations. It explains why guidelines sometimes change, why different expert panels may reach different conclusions on the same topic, and why consensus-based recommendations should be interpreted differently than conclusions from single studies.

Recognizing when consensus reflects strong evidence versus expert judgment in the absence of definitive data is essential for appropriate application.

References

  • Evidence vs Consensus in Clinical Practice Guidelines, JAMA
  • Going from evidence to recommendations, BMJ

← Back to Glossary