Scientific Consensus

← Back to Glossary

Definition

Scientific consensus represents the collective judgment of the scientific community on a particular question, based on the cumulative weight of published evidence, expert evaluation, and critical scrutiny over time.

Correct Scientific Usage

Consensus emerges through repeated testing, replication, peer review, and ongoing evaluation of evidence. It is not determined by vote or authority but by the strength and consistency of evidence. Scientists recognize that consensus is provisional and subject to revision as new evidence emerges.

Common Misunderstandings

Scientific consensus is sometimes portrayed as absolute certainty or dismissed as opinion. In reality, consensus represents the most reliable current understanding based on available evidence. Dissenting views are valued when supported by rigorous evidence, but skepticism alone does not constitute scientific disagreement.

Why It Matters

Understanding scientific consensus helps distinguish mainstream scientific understanding from fringe claims. It explains why established scientific positions carry more weight than individual contrarian opinions, while recognizing that science progresses by challenging and refining consensus through evidence.

References

  • Expert credibility in climate change, PNAS
  • Public Conceptions of Scientific Consensus, Erkenntnis

← Back to Glossary